The Overlooked Cybersecurity Risks Costing Small Businesses Thousands

Many small business owners believe cyber attacks are a problem reserved for large corporations with massive databases and global operations. The reality is very different: small businesses are the number one target for hackers. Why? Because attackers know that smaller companies often lack the same protections, making them easier to break into — and one simple mistake can cost thousands.

Here are some of the most common (and costly) cybersecurity risks small businesses face, and how to avoid them:

1. Weak or Shared Passwords

It may seem obvious, but I still see business owners and staff using “password123” or one universal login for the entire office. If that password is leaked, every part of your system is suddenly exposed.

Real-world example: A local boutique fitness studio used the same password across their booking system, payroll software, and email logins. One stolen password led to a week of downtime and hundreds of dollars in rebooked classes.

Risk Mitigation: Use strong, unique passwords for each system and enable multi-factor authentication whenever possible.

2. Believing the Processor Covers You

This is one of the biggest myths I hear: “We use Square, Stripe, or PayPal — so we’re covered.” These processors protect their systems, not yours. If your salon’s Wi-Fi is hacked or a staff member’s laptop is stolen, you are still responsible for customer data that was transmitted or stored through your business.

Real-world example: A nail salon’s tablet was stolen. Even though payments ran through Square, the client contact details saved on the device triggered costly notification and monitoring requirements.

Risk Mitigation: Understand your responsibility. Cyber liability insurance fills the gaps your payment processor doesn’t.

3. Employees Clicking Phishing Emails

Most breaches don’t begin with a sophisticated hacker. They start with a simple email. One click on a fake invoice, shipping notice, or job application can let ransomware into your system.

Real-world example: A medical office in Colorado paid more than $40,000 in recovery costs after an employee clicked an email attachment disguised as a patient referral.

Risk Mitigation: Train staff to slow down, verify sender addresses, and be cautious before opening attachments.

4. Outdated Software and Unsecured Wi-Fi

Hackers often don’t “break in” — they walk in through the digital equivalent of an unlocked door. Outdated software and unsecured Wi-Fi are among the easiest targets. This is especially dangerous for gyms and salons that offer guest WiFi, as it opens another entry point.

Risk Mitigation: Keep your systems updated and secure your networks with strong passwords. If you must provide guest Wi-Fi, ensure it is separated from your internal systems.

5. Thinking Cyber Insurance is Only for Big Companies

Many small business owners assume they’re “too small to matter.” The truth is the opposite. Hackers go after easy wins — and small businesses, with fewer defenses, are often the lowest-hanging fruit.

Real-world example: A local catering company was forced to pay for 18 months of credit monitoring for more than 600 clients after a breach. The costs nearly shut down their business.

Risk Mitigation: Protect your business with a cyber liability policy designed specifically for small business owners.

Heather's Final Thoughts

When a breach occurs, the financial impact isn’t limited to IT costs. Businesses face:

• Legal and regulatory fines

• Client notifications and credit monitoring (required in many states)

• Reputational damage that can take years to repair

• Lost income during downtime

For many small businesses, one breach could mean closing their doors for good.

Cyber liability isn’t about paranoia — it’s about protection. One weak password, one unsecured network, or one phishing email could disrupt everything you have worked to build. The good news is that with the right safeguards, and the right coverage, you can protect your business, your clients, and your business' reputation.

If you’re unsure whether your current insurance would protect you in the event of a cyber attack, let’s schedule a review.

Initial Consultation

30min

Book Now